Supreme Court of the United States December 22, 1879, 101 (West v. Smith)

Also known as

United States · · · 22-12-1879

Me. Justice -Cliffoed

delivered the opinion of the court.

Due removal of the suit before the court was made from the State court where it was commenced, into the Circuit Court, in which case it is no longer usual to file new pleadings, the act of Congress providing that the practice, pleadings, and forms and modes of proceeding in common-law actions shall conform, as near as may be, to the practice, pleadings, and forms and modes of proceeding existing at the time, in like causes, in the courts of record of the State within which such Circuit Court is held, any rule of court to the contrary notwithstanding. 17 St at. 197 ; Rev. Stats., sect. 914.

Sufficient appears to show that the writ in the- practice of the State courts-contains the declaration,, the command of the same to the sheriff being that he shall summon the defendant to appear and answer to the plaintiff in a certain plea, wherein is set forth the cause of action. Pursuant to that practice, the defendants in this case were summoned to appear in a plea of the case, the declaration containing two counts in assumpsit, — the first being a count for goods sold and delivered, in the sum of $8,000, in two forms; the second being a count for work and labor done and performed, in the sum of $8,000, at the special instance and request of the defendants. Both counts are in the usual form, and the declaration concludes with the usual breach alleging non-payment, to the damage of the plaintiffs in thé sum of $10,000. Personal service was made; and the. defendants having appeared and removed the cause into the Circuit Court, pleaded the general issue that tfeey never did assume and promise in manner and form as the plaintiffs in their declaration have alleged, and tendered an issue to the country.

Special matter may be given in evidence .-under the general issue, according to the State practice, if previous notice be -given by the defendant or defendants.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.