Supreme Court of North Carolina June 5, 1880 (McKeithan v. . McGill)

Also known as

United States · · · 05-06-1880

Ashe, J.

It may now be considered as settled law that the act of 1789 is a bar to the action of a creditor when the defendant pleads that he has advertised, paid over the assets to the next of kin, and taken refunding bonds, according to law.

Cooper

v.

Cherry,

8 Jones, 323;

Reeves

v.

Bell,

2 Jones, 254. And so is the act of 1715, if there is a claim, and a

*519

person capable of suing, when seven years have elapsed .since the death of the debtor if the debt was due in his lifetime, or since the cause-of action accrued when the débfc became due after his death.

Alexander

v.

Alexander,

1. Car. L. R., 273 ;

Godley

v.

Taylor,

3 Dev., 178;

Jones

v.

Brodie,

3 Mur, 594;

Bailey

v.

Shannonhouse,

1 Dev. Eq., 416.

If this were an open question we should concur with the opinion expressed by Chief Justice Ruffin, in the case of

Rayner

v.

Watford, 2

Dev. 338, that the act of 1715 made an absolute bar after the lapse of seven years from.the death of the debtor, but we regard the construction of that aet as settled in the case of

Godley

v.

Taylor, supra.,

in which case Chief Justice Ruffin, though dissenting, says, “ although my former opinion has been confirmed by reflection, but in future I shall consider myself under equal obligation to hold for law what I understand in conference with my elder brethren to be their opinion that is, if the debt be due at the death of the debtor, claim must be made within seven years from the .death, otherwise both the heir and the executor are discharged ; and if the action arise after the death of the debtor, suit must be brought within seven years from the time the action accrued, or the heir and executor will in that case be discharged; and if the suit be brought against the executor within seven years from the death of the debtor, and the executor hath, at the time of the suit brought, not paid over the assets, he shall answer the demand; but if he hath paid them over, he shall haye the plea of fully administered found for him.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.