Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court November 23, 1880 (Commonwealth v. Certain Intoxicating Liquors)
Also known as
United States · · · 23-11-1880
Lord, J.
A single question only is presented in this bill of exceptions. That question is, Was the officer who served the warrant issued by Francis M. Thompson, a trial justice, authorized to make return of the warrant to William S. Dana, another trial justice, and did such return give to Dana jurisdiction of the cause ?
We have no doubt that such return was unauthorized, and that the justice who assumed to act in the premises had no jurisdiction.
*30It is true that from the earliest period it has been the practice for an officer to make return of a warrant committed to him to some justice other than the one who issued it; but that has been because the warrant has expressly authorized him to return it before any justice, comm aliquo justiciarum nostrorum ad pacem, &c.; a form of warrant which from a very early time has been authorized by the common law. 2 Hale P. C.112. Foster's case, 5 Rep. 59 a. It is stated in Hale P. G. that a justice may make the warrant to bring the prisoner before any of his Majesty’s justices of the peace, or before him who issued it, or any other justice; “ and then it is in the election of the officer to bring him before which justice of the county he pleases.” Or it might be issued without any such special direction, in which case it was returnable only before the magistrate who issued it.
The precise question which is raised in this case is whether an officer may in his own discretion make return of the warrant before any other magistrate than the one who issued it, when such authority is not expressed in the warrant. The claim of the Commonwealth is, that, inasmuch as the St. of 1876, c.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit