Supreme Court of Arkansas November 15, 1880 (Hamilton & Co. v. Duty)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-11-1880

English, C. J.

On the nineteenth of December, 1878, R B. and H. C. Duty brought an action of replevin against George "W. Cheatham, for three bales of cotton before a justice of the peace of Lafayette county.

In an affidavit filed by the plaintiffs, they describe the three bales of cotton, state their value, etc., that they were the owners and entitled to the immediate possession of the cotton, and that it was unlawfully detained by the defendant without right, etc. An order of delivery, and summons were issued to a constable, returnable on the twenty-first of December; and upon the execution of a bond by the plaintiff's, he took possession of the cotton, and delivered it to them, and served defendant with a copy of the order, and summoned him, etc.

On the twenty-fourth of December, on the application of Hamilton & Co., an order was entered on the docket of the justice making them parties to the suit, and the case continued to the second of January, 1879.

On the last-named day, Hamilton & Co. (a firm of merchants composed of W. E. and W. B. Hamilton) filed an answer to the affidavit and complaint of plaintiffs, in which, in substance, they alleged that the three bales of cotton therein described belonged to them, and not to the plaintiffs, and that defendant Cheatham had no interest therein. They also caused to be entered on the docket of the justice, in short, a denial of each and all of the allegations of plaintiffs’ complaint, and particularly that they were the owners of the cotton, etc, and alleging ownership and right of possession in themselves, and claiming judgment, etc.

Cheatham filed no answer, and set up no claim to the cotton. It seems that when the suit was commenced, it was in his possession as agent of Hamilton & Co.

All the parties appearing, the ease was submitted to a jury, and they returned a verdict that the cotton was the property of the plaintiff's, and the justice rendered judgment that they retain the cotton, and recover costs of defendants.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.