Utah Supreme Court June 15, 1880 (Cooke v. Young)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-06-1880
BoRemaN, J".,
delivered the opinion of the court:
The appellants and respondents were adverse applicants under the “ town site ” laws, for the government title to a certain parcel of land in Salt Lake City. The Probate Court having awarded the ground to the appellant, the respondent appealed to the District Court, wherein judgment was rendered for the respondent, and thereupon the said Young appealed to this court.
A person named Wadsworth was in possession of the ground in controversy in 1860. He sold his claim to Brigham Young and then gave up the possession. Brigham Young authorized the respondent to take possession and occupy the property, and from 1860 to the present time the respondent has occupied and possessed the ground.
In February, 1872, Brigham Young deeded the ground to Hyram S. Young, the appellant. The respondent claims title by her actual lona, fide occupancy, and the appellant sets up no claim to individual occupancy by himself or his grantor, Brigham Young, but he claims the respondent to be his tenant and that, therefore, her occupancy was his occupancy.
This court has heretofore, in several cases, held that an actual, bona fide personal occupancy of the ground claimed was necessary to entitle anyone to the deed of the mayor for the government title. Cain Heirs v. Young, 1 Utah R. 361; *258Hussy v. Smith, 1 Utah R. 129; Pratt v. Young, 1 Utah R. 347.
In these cases it is also held that no one can take np these city lots by means of agents, or rather that no such rights could be recognized in ascertaining to whom the government title should go, but that every claimant must be himself an actual settler, an occupant taking up the land for his own “ use and benefit,” and not for another. The policy of the law was to give the land to actual settlers and not to speculators.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit