Supreme Court of Vermont January 15, 1880 (Whitcomb v. Denio)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-01-1880

The opinion of the court was delivered by

Ross J.

A purchaser induced to make a purchase by fraud, on discovering the fraud, may affirm the contract and bring an action to recover the damages occasioned by the fraud ; or, if it is then in his power to place the vendor in statu quo, he may tender back the purchase, rescind the contract, and, if the price is unpaid, defend when sued for its recovery, or, if the price of the purchase has been paid, sustain an action against the vendor for the money paid. Such contracts are not void, but voidable at the election of the defrauded party. In whichever form of action the question may arise, the establishment of the fact that the contract was induced by fraud, is material, and any legitimate evidence to prove such fact, admissible. In our judgment the evidence objected and excepted to, tended to establish that the plaintiffs were induced to purchase the notes by the fraud of the defendant. If *389believed by the jury it showed that the defendant not only stated that the notes were good, but that they were secured by mortgage on seventy-five acres of land in Fairfield, and that there was no other mortgage or claim on said land, which last was then known to the defendant to be false. The whole of the defendant’s representations on that occasion respecting the notes was admissible, although some selected portions thereof, if standing alone, would be but the expression of an opinion, and for that reason would not subject the defendant to an action for their falsity. This is probably true of the naked representation that the notes were good and all right, but, when taken altogether, this expression of opinion is supported and made to rest on a statement of what he claimed to be facts personally known by him, in regard to how the notes were secured, and that they were a first and only claim on the security, which statement is shown to have been then known by him to be false. This evidence was properly admitted.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.