Oregon Supreme Court January 15, 1880 (Allen v. Hirsch)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-01-1880

By the Court,

Kelly, C. J.:

The question here presented for consideration is, whether the several acts of the legislative assembly referred to in the appellant’s petition authorizing the construction of the Dalles and Sandy road and the Eastern Oregon and Winnemucca wagon road are constitutional.

Article 4, section 23, subdivision 7, of the constitution is as follows: “The legislative assembly shall not pass *422special or local laws in any of the following enumerated cases; that is to say * * * 7. For laying, opening, and working on highways, and for the election or appointment of supervisors.” It is claimed by the counsel for. respondent, that these acts are special and local in their character, and therefore in conflict with the provision of the constitution just quoted, and the warrants drawn under and in pursuance of them are, therefore, necessarily void. Blackstone says: “Statutes are either generator special, public or private. A general or public act is an universal rule that regards the whole community; and of this the courts of law are bound to take notice judicially and ecc officio. Special or private acts are rather exceptions than rules, being those which only operate upon particular persons and private concerns.” (1 Bl. Com. 85.) The words “general” and “public” are here used as expressing the same kind of statutes. So, also, special statutes are, according to the common law definition, synonymous with private statutes. The early elementary law writers seem to have made no distinction between a private and a local statute, but define private acts to be those which related to particular persons or classes of men, or which related to a particular place o.r town. (Burrill’s Law Dict., voce “Private Statute;” Bac. Abr., Statute F; 1 Kent’s Com. 459.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.