The Superior Court of New York City April 5, 1880 (Hathaway v. Russell)
Also known as
United States · · · 05-04-1880
By the Court.—Sedgwick, J.
The statement of the proceedings discloses that numerons and novel matters of practice are involved. The referee to hear and determine proceeded so far as to determine that the plaintiff was entitled to an accounting as to certain matters. Whether he might have proceeded to the accounting without a further order (Ludington v. Taft, 10 Barb. 447), or whether the referee should have re*108ported as he did, and then an interlocutory judgment have been moved upon notice (Bantes v. Brady, 8 How. Pr. 216), or whether the order entered should have been made ex parte, or whether the appellant, if he be aggrieved by that, should not have before appealing moved to set it aside, or whether, in fact, the so called interlocutory judgment is anything more than an order directing the referee to do what by the first order of reference he was ordered to do, are questions "which have not been brought before the court on this appeal by counsel for either side,—for the reason, it must be-supposed, that if they are not immaterial, the counsel do not wish that the decision of the appeal should turn upon them.
The only points that the appellant’s counsel present on the argument, and that concern the former practice of the proceeding, are two. It is submitted, first, that the referee has failed to order any judgment in his report, as required by law and section 1,022 of the Code of Civil Procedure. I do not see that this is correct, in view of the report “that the defendant should be ordered and adjudged to account, &c.” This certainly is a judgment directed, and if the objection be, that the referee should have proceeded to the accounting and determined if anything were due, the appellant is not harmed, because the order appealed from directs no more than that he shall do so.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit