Supreme Court of North Carolina October 5, 1881 (Jones v. Commissioners of Rowan)

Also known as

United States · · · 05-10-1881

Ashe, J.

The'detnurrer ought not to have been sustained5 by his Honor. The first cause assigned was too indefinite^ and the second was defective in that it assigned as cause of demurrer that the action should have been against the board of commissioners and not against the individuals constituting the board, when in fact, the action was against the-board and not against the individual members thereof.

It is true, the names of the members of the board are mentioned in the summons, but that was surplusage, and the “board of commissioners” in its corporate capacity was by the terms of the process, the real defendant. It was so considered in the argument before us, for the responsibility of the

county of

Rowan was strenuously insisted upon.

But while we hold that the demurrer must be overruled, the motion to dismiss the action made by the defendants” counsel, under section 99 C. C. P., upon the ground the complaint did not set forth facts sufficient to constitute a cause-of action, presents the same objection as that intended to be raised by the demurrer.

The question presented is one of very considerable importance and of the first impression in this state. The-question is nothing more nor less than this :. Is it the duty of a county through its officers to re-assess the allotments-of homesteads and personal property exemptions, which have been made by appraisers, upon applications for re-assessment ? and are they liable in damages for the neglect of their officers to perform that duty?

*281

We cannot believe that it was the intention of the legislature to impose such a duty or liability upon the counties. There is nothing in the act of 1868 or that of 1876-’7 which warrants such a construction.

By the act of 1868-’9, ch.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.