New York Court of Common Pleas June 6, 1881 (Tysen v. Tompkins)

Van Brunt, J.

[After stating the facts as above.]—The objections which were made to the ruling of the court below are these:—

Fi/rst. That it was error to hold that the proceedings before the justice upon Staten Island were a bar to the defense interposed in this action; and

Secondly.