The Superior Court of New York City May 15, 1881 (Sewell v. Ives)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-05-1881

Speir, J.

It has been decided by this and other courts that the seat of a member in the Exchange was property in every proper sense of the term and could be sold, and was transferrable as any other species of property having actual value as such. The price realized by the defendant was $4,000, which *56is proof of its then value. It was proved, and the court on the former trial found that the plaintiff paid, on his admission to the board, for his seat, $2,000.

The Hew York Exchange being composed of more than seven persons, owning and having an interest in property in common, and who would be liable to an action on account,, of such ownership and interest, this action, being brought by the plaintiff, a member, iu relation to his interest in that property, is properly brought against the defendant," as president.

Although the plaintiff is a suspended member of the Hew York Exchange, it having been held and decided by this court that his alleged expulsion-therefrom was void and of no effect, it clearly follows that the sale of his seat by the board having been made solely upon the ground of his wrongful expulsion, the Exchange have become by that act responsible to the plain-for any injury or damage done thereby. It is not disputed that the sale was made by the defendant, and that it realized thereon the sum of $4,000.

It is claimed that the proceeds of this sale were applied to the payment of the plaintiff’s debts in the Exchange, and that such payment is in mitigation of damages if not in bar to the action. If this be so it must be upon the assumption that the defendant had authority to dispose of the seat, and to receive and appropriate the proceeds of the sale to his creditors. Under the facts in the case.no such authority is shown, nor can any be inferred, as all the proceedings on defendant’s part were wholly, illegal and void. ,.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.