Appellate Court of Illinois October 11, 1881 (T. Cumins & Co. v. Leighton)
Also known as
United States · · · 11-10-1881
Lacey, J.
This was a suit originally commenced before a justice of the peace, and tried in the circuit court on appeal. The appellants were plaintiffs, and the appellee was defendant in the court below. The suit was based on two promissory ■ notes given by appellee to appellants; the principal and interest amounted at the time of the trial in the circuit court, to . the sum of $250.42. °
On the trial the execution of the notes was admitted, and it was also admitted that appellants had sent the notes for collection to one J. N. Conger, a banker. It was the Oneida Exchange Bank of which Clarence Conger was clerk or assistant cashier during the time of the alleged payment. The appellee claimed that he paid the' notes to Clarence Conger at his (Leighton’s) store in Oneida, between ten and eleven o’clock, Oct. 4, 1873. This alleged payment was the only question in issue.
The evidence in the case on the question of payment was very conflicting, and apparently pretty evenly balanced.
Appellee testified that Clarence Conger brought the notes into his store about ten or eleven o’clock, on Oct. 4,1873, and that he paid both of them to him.
This was entirely denied by the evidence of Clarence Conger, supported by evidence tending to show that he was in Chicago, or on his way there at that time.
Appellee further testified that after he had paid the notes, he went to the store, asked Gilbert Dugan to take his feet down so he could get the stove door open, and then said as he put the notes into the stove, “Those damned notes wont trouble me any more.” “ Dugan asked what notes they were; I then told him they were the Deere and Grand Detour plow notes. ” “ I told this while in the act of burning them. ” Appellee could not say that Clarence was there when he made the remarks on throwing them into the stove.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit