Supreme Judicial Court of Maine February 20, 1882 (Bragg v. Dole)
Also known as
United States · · · 20-02-1882
Virgin, J.
When were the defendants obliged to accept a deed of the premises leased to them, or pay the liquidated damages stipulated for their refusal ?
Their covenant answers : "At the expiration of said term, or so soon as the lessor shall acquire an absolute title to said premises and be able to convey the same,” — thus fixing upon one intended to be specific and certain, and another, different and uncertain, but both really contingent upon the redemption of the mortgage under which alone the lessor held.
When was the "expiration of the term?”
Shephard’s ninth rule "to be universally observed for exposition of all kinds of deeds and of all parts thereof,” requires, "that the construction be made upon the entire deed, and that one part of it doth help to expound another, and that every word (if it may be) may take effect and none be rejected.” Law Com. Assur. c. 3, § 2. This rule variously expressed has been universally recognized.
Applying the rule and seeking for the intention of the parties exclusively within the language adopted by them in their deed, "e* antecedentibus et consequentibus,” we find the recital that the lessor’s title is that of mortgagee. The term of the lease is therein expressly limited to the period of " three years from May 9,1877, subject only to the legal right of redemption from said mortgage by any one having the right to redeem.” This modification evidently rendered the "term” potentially less, but not more than the number of years specified. In harmony with this the next succeeding clause limits the time for paying rent to " so long as said term shall last, or until the premises shall be redeemed.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit