Hawaii Supreme Court May 31, 1882 (A. W. Peirce & Co. v. Briggs)

Also known as

United States · · · 31-05-1882

Opinion of the Court by

Judd, C. J.

This ease comes to this Court in Banco from the Intermediary Court of Oahu, with the stipulation that it shall be *492decisive of four other cases against the same defendants, to wit: The cases of J. T. Waterhouse, Messrs. Tibbetts & Sorenson, G. West, and C. E. Williams.

The following are the facts: A piece of land in Honolulu was purchased of John Ena, Jr., by Robert Briggs and the conveyance therefor made to A. J. Cartwright as trustee for Mrs. Eugenia Briggs, the wife of Robert Briggs. This conveyance contained a provision, in substance, that the trustee should convey the estate to whoever Mrs. Briggs should nominate. She nominated herself, and Mr. Cartwright accordingly conveyed the estate to her, and on the 81st of March, 1880, she and her husband joined in executing a mortgage to Mr. Cartwright of the premises.

Under a power of sale in the mortgage a sale was effected by the mortgagee, Mr. Cartwright. He was summoned as garnishee and stated that the surplus in his hands, after satisfying the mortgage debt was about $1,000. The mortgage contains this clause: “And the surplus, if any, shall be paid to the said Eugenia Briggs, her executors, administrators and assigns.”

Mi\ Briggs gave his attorney an order on Cartwright for the money, which was presented and payment refused as Mrs. Briggs also claimed the money.

The plaintiffs were all pre-existing creditors before the mortgage was given.

The question is, whether the proceeds of the sale of the ¡wife’s land are available by the garnishee process to the creditors of the husband.

Our statutes declare that the wife’s real estate is not liable for ‘the husband’s debts, but her personal estate is his by virtue of marriage. Civil Code, Section 1,286.

Is the fund attached personal property of the wife?

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.