Wisconsin Supreme Court October 10, 1882 (Moritz v. Splitt)

Also known as

United States · · · 10-10-1882

Cassoday, J.

There can be no question but what the appeal from the judgment brings up for review the order sustaining the demurrer upon which it is based. The statute so declares, whenever the order “involves the merits and necessarily affects the judgment.” Sec. 3010, R. S. This court has frequently so held. Breed v. Ketchum, 51 Wis., 166; Webster v. Ins. Co., 36 Wis., 67; Armstrong v. Gibson, 31 Wis., 61; Sweet v. Mitchell, 17 Wis., 125. The only ground of the demurrer is that the “ complaint does not state facts sufficient to constitute a cause of action.” Obviously the demurrer was not well taken, if the complaint does state facts sufficient to constitute a cause of action. That it *443does, seems to be conceded; but the contention is that it fails to state the facts necessary to entitle the plaintiff to a lien upon the premises in question for the amount of his claim, which is a part of the relief demanded. But the mere fact that the allegations of the complaint do not entitle the plaintiff to all the relief prayed for, is no ground for holding that it states no cause of action, when, in fact, it does state a good cause of action, for which judgment may be taken as a part of the relief demanded in the complaint. Such ground of demurrer can only be sustained when the complaint states no cause of action whatever. Bronson v. Markey, 53 Wis., 98: Wheeler v. Hall, 41 Wis., 447.

It is claimed, however, that an action to enforce a mechanic’s lien is made by the revised statutes an equitable action, and hence must necessarily state a cause for equitable relief. But the statute expressly provides that “if the plaintiff in any such action fail to establish his lien, . . . but establishes a right to recover upon contract for his alleged work and labor done, or materials furnished, he may have a personal judgment in the action against the party liable for the amount due him, ... in like manner as if the action were for the recovery of money only.” Sec. 3324, E. S.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.