Michigan Supreme Court January 18, 1882 (Cody v. Phelps)

Also known as

United States · · · 18-01-1882

lead-opinion

Marston, J.

It is admitted that the lease from the executors, of the lands whereon the wheat in question was grown, was invalid and that Peter Cody, as assignee thereof, would have had no right to the possession of the premises thereunder as against the heirs or those claiming under them. The evidence tends to show quite strongly, and the jury must have so found, that Peter Cody abandoned his family. After that time the executor’s lease was surrendered up and a new lease from the heirs taken. This lease upon the face thereof appeared to run to Peter Cody. The draftsman signed Peter Cody’s name to the lease and Mrs. Cody, who could not write, made her mark thereto, or a mark as though executing it for her husband. The wheat was sown and harvested under this lease.

Under the facts shown in this case it does not appear that Mrs. Cody had any authority whatever to execute this lease for her husband Peter Cody. He was not bound by her act, and he could not have been held liable for the rent thereon. As he was not a party therefore to this lease, and did not *433put in any crop upon the lands or have any knowledge, even, thereof, we think it cannot be said that he was the owner of the crops grown thereunder. Mrs. Cody after his abandonment was in fact the head of the family, and if she and her minor children cultivated this land, she is entitled to the-crops grown thereon and could maintain an action therefor.

The judgment should be affirmed with costs.

Campbell and Cooley, JJ. concurred.

dissent

Graves, C. J.

dissenting. As my views differ from those held by a majority of the court I proceed to explain them.

Phelps took several loads of unthreshed wheat on an execution against the husband of Mrs. Cody and she sued in trover and was allowed to recover. Several questions relating to evidence were raised but the main point concerned her right of property. The husband and wife were living on his farm which with the assistance of his two sons he carried on.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.