Supreme Court of the United States March 18, 1882, 191 (Warnock v. Davis)

Also known as

United States · · · 18-03-1882

Mr. Justice Field,

after stating the facts, delivered the opinion of the court, as follows: —

As seen from the statement of the case, the evidence before the court was not conflicting, and it was only necessary to meet the general allegations of the first defence. All the facts established by it are admitted in the other defences. The court could not have ruled in favor of the defendants without holding that the agreement between the deceased and the Scioto Trust Association was valid, and that the assignment transferred to if the right to nine-tenths of the money collected on the policy. For alleged error in these particulars the plaintiff asks a reversal of the judgment.

The policy executed on the life of the deceased was' a valid contract, and as such was assignable by the assured to the association as security for any sums' lent to him, or advanced for the premiums and assessments upon it. But it -was not assignable

*779

to the association for any other purpose. The association had no insurable interest in the life of the deceased, and could not have taken out a policy in its own name. Such a policy would constitute what is termed a wager policy, or a mere speculative contract upon the life of the assured, with a direct interest in its early termination.

It is,not easy to define with precision what will in all cases constitute an insurable interest, so as to take the contract out of the class-of wager policies. It may be stated generally, however, to be such an interest, arising from the relations of the party obtaining the insurance, either as creditor of or ■surety for the assured, or from the ties of blood or marriage to him, as will justify a reasonable expectation of advantage or benefit from the continuance of his life.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.