Supreme Court of the United States March 13, 1882, 210 (United States v. Temple)
Also known as
United States · · · 13-03-1882
Me. Justice Woods,
after stating the facts, delivered the opinion of the court.
The statute and the finding of the Court of Claims leave little room for controversy. The law as it stood when the travel was performed was explicit, and .is not open to construetion. We find in it no warrant for the .distinction made by the accounting officers of the treasury between travel by sea
*99
and travel on land within the United States, performed by ah officer of the navy while engaged on public business. To hold that for one class of travel he should have eight cents per mile, and for the other his actual expenses, is to make the law and not to construe it. When this travel was performed there was nót a line on the statute-book of the United States which made any provision whatever, under any circumstances, for allowing- officers of the navy,. when engaged on the public business,, their actual expenses of travel- The only law ever enacted which made such provision had been expressly repealed by the act on which the appellee based his claim for mileage. This act declared him entitled, without condition or limitation, to miléage'át the rate of eight cents per, mile, and is the only law upon the subject.
.. Our duty is to read the statute according to the natural and obvious import of the language, without resorting to subtle and forced construction for the purpose of either limiting 'or extending its operation.
Waller
v.
Harris,
20 Wend. (N. Y.) 561;
Pott v. Arthur,
104 U. S. 735. When the 'language is plain,'we have no right to insert words and phrases,'so. as to incorporate ,in the .statute a new and distinct provision.
The attempt to justify the decision of the accounting officers of the treasury is based on an alleged practice in conformity therewith, which, it is said, grew, up in the Navy Department under the act of 1835. The practice, if such there was, finds no higher warrant or sanction in the act of 1835 than in the aet of 1876.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit