Supreme Court of the United States March 13, 1882, 1187 (Bennecke v. Insurance Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 13-03-1882

Mr. Justice Woods,

after stating the case, delivered the opinion of the court.

It is not disputed by the plaintiff, that, upon the facts found, the poliey of insurance had been forfeited. It is not insisted .that the company by its agent formally waived the forfeiture, or issued any permit to Bennecke, from which such waiver could be inferred.

But the plaintiff contends that, after the forfeiture of the policy, Ansley, the agent of the company at Bloomington, having on October 17 received the sum usually charged for a permit to reside south of the' thirty-second parallel, between the 1st of July.and the 1st of November, and sent it on the same day to the agents of the company at Chicago, its receipt by them, and the fact that they never returned it to the person by whom it Ayas paid, áre sufficient to establish the company’s waiver of the forfeiture.

It does not appear from the findings that either the agent at Bloomington, or those at C&icago, had any direct authority to W£¿ve a forfeiture. But even if it were shown that they had such authority, and had waived the forfeiture, or that the company itself had waived it, the waiver Avould not, under the-circumstances of this, case, be binding on the company.

A Avaiver of a stipulation in an agreement must, to be effectual, not only be made intentionally, but with knowledge of-the circumstances. This is the rule'when there is a direct and precise agreement to waive the stipulation.

A fortiori

is this the rule when there is no agreement either verbal or in writing to waive the' stipulation, but where it is sought to dedupe a waiver from the conduct of .the party. Thus, wherq.a-Ayritten

*360

agreement exists and one of the parties sets up an arrangement of a different nature, alleging conduct on, the other side amounting to a substitution of this arrangement for a written agreement, he must clearly show not merely his own understanding, but that the. other party had the same understanding.

Darnley (Earl)

v.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.