New York Surrogate's Court January 15, 1883 (Gillies v. Kreuder)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-01-1883

The Surrogate.

The objection taken on behalf of the administratrix is quite technical. The order to show cause is entitled in the original proceeding, and the order itself refers to the decree made therein, a copy of which had been served upon her, so that she could not have been misled. I think the order may, under the provisions of § 723 of the Code made applicable to Surrogates’ courts by § 2538, be amended, or the mistake be disregarded.

*351As to the merits of the matter, I do not see why Mrs. Kreuder should not obey the decree by paying the costs. Her counsel seemed to think the amount of costs large, and so, at first, it would appear, when, on a motion made in the Supreme Court, as provided by § 1380, only ten dollars can be allowed. But, it will be seen that the cases are different. In the latter court, a mere motion, on notice to the parties interested, is made, and results in making an order granting or denying the motion, and is, under § 767, a mere order, because it is not contained in a judgment. Such a direction, in this court, if not included in a decree, is a mere order, and the costs of that would be the same as in the Supreme Court (§ 2556). But in this case, the statute distinctly defines the direction of the court to be a decree (§§ 1380, 1381, Throop's Code, and Notes). To obtain it, a petition must be presented, citations issued, and appropriate proceedings be had on its return. Precisely what questions may be tried, the statute fails to indicate, any farther than the general direction to the Surrogate to make such decree as may seem just. It is said, in the case of the Marine Bank v. Van Brunt (49 N. Y., 161), that the Surrogate, on such an application, can regulate and adjust the equities of different claimants upon the estate, and provide for a proper preservation and distribution of the assets, while the court of law can only determine the legal rights of the individual judgment debtor.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.