Supreme Court of Minnesota December 5, 1883 (Berkey v. Judd)

Also known as

United States · · · 05-12-1883

Vanderburgh, J.

The duty of the executors who are named as-defendants to pay the judgment in controversy was finally determined, in the case of Berkey v. Judd, 27 Minn. 475. This action against, them and their surety, Sabin, is brought by leave of the probate court-upon their bond, because of their alleged neglect and refusal to pay-such judgment-, and this appeal is from an order overruling their demurrer to the complaint.

1. The principal contention of the defendants is that the complaint: fails to show a breach of the condition of the bond, for the reason, that the probate court has not formally’ordered the payment of the-judgment. Upon the facts admitted by the demurrer, it became the. duty of the probate court, after the rendition of the original judg-’ ment, (22 Minn. 287,) the recovery of which had been resisted by the executors, and of which they were fully cognizant, to order the *274amount thereof paid; and accordingly, ugon the petition of the plaintiff, such court ordered the executors to show cause why they should not pay the same. Upon the hearing, they answered, admitting that no other claims remained unsettled, and that they had in their hands ample assets to pay the amount of the judgment, but insisting that the same was barred because it had not been duly presented to the commissioners appointed to audit claims against the estate; and thereupon, on their motion, the court denied the plaintiff’s application, and, from the order refusing to direct such, payment, the plaintiff appealed to the district court under Gen. St. 1878, c. 49, § 13, where the order of the probate court was reversed, and judgment ordered for the plaintiff, which was affirmed in the supreme court, (Berkey v. Judd, 27 Minn. 475.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.