Mississippi Supreme Court October 15, 1883 (Vicksburg & Meridian Railroad v. Lowry)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-10-1883

Campbell, C. J.,

delivered the opinion of the court.

The money alleged to be in the State treasury, and sought to be obtained by this proceeding, was required to be placed there subject to the requisition of the governor in carrying into effect the act applying the two per cent, fund, and can be drawn under said act only on the requisition of the governor. The court cannot dirfeot the treasurer to pay without the requisition of the governor. The petition avers that the governor has refused to make such requisition, and it makes the governor and treasurer parties defendant and prays mandamus to the treasurer to compel him to pay the money. There is no prayer for mandamus to the governor. It is clear that the treasurer cannot pay without the requisition of the governor, and we might dispose of the case on the ground that a mandamus to the governor is not prayed by the petition; but as the governor is a party, and the appellant may bring his petition to compel the governor to make the requisition needed, and thus present the question of its right to a mandamus for that purpose, we meet it now.

Can a mandamus be issued to the governor in any case? It has been held by some courts that the governor may be compelled by mandamus to perform ministerial acts; but the overwhelming-weight of authority is in favor of the denial of the writ against the governor in any case. In Arkansas, Georgia, Florida, Illinois, Louisiana, Maine, Michigan, Minnesota, Missouri, New Jersey, Rhode Island, Tennessee, and Texas, it is held that mandamus cannot be issued against the governor, and the decisions are supported by the most satisfactory reasons arising from the nature of our gov-*104eminent, which consists of distinct departments which are independent and must be so maintained. Hawkins v. Governor, 1 Ark. 570; Bisbee v. Drew, Gov., 17 Fla. 67; Low v. Towns, 8 Ga. 360; People v. Bissell, 19 Ill. 229; People v. Yates, 40 Ill. 126; State v. Warmoth, 22 La. Ann.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.