Supreme Court of Missouri October 15, 1883 (Pulliam v. Burlingame)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-10-1883

Martin, O.

The plaintiff brought an action of replevin in the circuit court for the recovery of two mules, alleging that he was “ the owner of, and entitled to the immediate possession of ” the same. The defendant in answer made a general denial of the facts alleged in the petition. The case was tried by the court, a jury being waived by the parties.

Plaintiff’ offered testimony tending to prove that he was the owner and in possession of the mules in controversy ; that about the month of February, 1880, defendant borrowed said mules from plaintiff’, but said nothing then about his wife’s interest in or claim to same, That defend*114ant held said mules, until they were taken out of his possession under the writ in this cause.

The defendant then offered, and the coui’t heard testimony tending to show that Martha E. Burlingame was the sister.of plaintiff’, and wife of defendant; that she owned jointly with plaintiff' an undivided half interest in said mules at the time they were borrowed by her husband, and also at the time they were taken from defendant under the writ aforesaid. Defendant also introduced evidence showing that he was in possession of said mules at the time they were replevied in this cause, as the agent of his wife; that he was simply holding the same with and for his wife, by reason of her half interest aforesaid. This was all the testimony offered.

The court, at the instance of plaintiff, declared the law as follows:

“ If the court, sitting as a jury, believe from the evidence that the defendant borrowed the mules from the plaintiff’ and refused to return them to him when so requested, the court will find the right of possession in the plaintiff'.”

The defendant requested the court, which the latter refused to do, to declare the law as follows:

“If the court, sitting as a jury, believe from the evidence that at the time of the service of the writ herein, said defendant was the husband of one Martha E. Burlingame ; that said Martha E.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.