Supreme Court of New Jersey November 15, 1883 (Lattan v. Royal Insurance)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-11-1883

The opinion of the court was delivered by

Depue, J.

The plaintiffs cannot recover the balance of the adjusted loss on the promise of the defendant contained in the agreement of June 12th, 1875. That promise to pay was made to Righter’s administrators, and was conditional upon their failure to recover a verdict in the suit they had brought against the Hibernia company; and it was an implied condi*457tion that that suit should be prosecuted to a verdict one way •or the other. The suit was not so prosecuted. It was non grossed for'the failure to file a declaration. The result of this suit must be determined on questions of law, independent of the agreement of June 12th, 1875.

The clause in the defendant’s policy with respect to other insurance was part of its contract of insurance. It was one of the terms of the agreement between the parties that in case there should be other insurance upon the property, the company should pay only its ratable proportion of the damages sustained by reason of the fire. The Hibernia policy had been taken out before the defendant’s policy was issued. It was taken out for a term of insurance that covered the time when the fire occurred. If that policy was in force when the fire happened, it was other insurance, within the meaning of the defendant’s policy, and in that event the defendant is liable only for a ratable proportion of the loss.

The assured was put under no obligation to the defendants to keep up the Hibernia policy. He might consent to or submit to the cancellation of the Hibernia policy before a loss •occurred, without affecting his rights under the defendant’s policy. Hand v. Williamsburgh Ins. Co., 57 N. Y. 41, 47. The condition of things to which the clause in the defendant’s policy had reference was the existence, in fact, of other insurance on the property at the time of the fire.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.