Missouri Court of Appeals November 20, 1883 (Garrett v. Cramer)
Also known as
United States · · · 20-11-1883
Thompson, J.,
delivered the opinion of the court.
This action was commenced before a justice of the peace upon a statutory undertaking, whereby the defendant engaged, in a suit pending in the circuit court of the then County of St. Louis, between John H. Graf, by next friend, plaintiff, andC. Borgdorf, defendant, to pay all costs which had accrued or which might accrue in the suit. The undertaking was entered into in conformity with a rule upon the plaintiff to give such security, on motion of the defendant. It was in the following language: —
“ I acknowledge myself bound for all costs that have accrued or may accrue in the case of John H. Graf, by next *402friend, against C. Borgdorf and all. Witness my hand at seal at St. Louis this day of 3d February, 1874.
“(Signed) Henry Cramer [l. s.].
“Approved by the court February 3d, 1874.
“ J. Lewis, OlerTc.”
It appeared at the trial that the plaintiff was one of thirteen witnesses who had been examined for the plaintiff in that suit and whose fees, taxed at various sums from $30.55, the amount of this plaintiff’s fees, to $5.80, the amount of those of the witness, John P. Graf. In the suit in which this undertaking was given the judgment was rendered in favor of the plaintiff and against one of the defendants. Evidence was also introduced tending to show that the parties to the suit in which this undertaking was given were all of them insolvent and had no property within the city or county of St. Louis subject to execution. We do not see that anj^ evidence was offered tending to show whether the other twelve witnesses in favor of whom witness fees were taxed in the case of Graf v. Borgdorf have been paid their fees or not.
Upon this evidence the question which arises is whether the plaintiff is entitled to maintain this action. The defendant takes the ground that he is not, for two reasons: (1.) That he is not the obligee in the bond sued on. (2.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit