U.S. Circuit Court for the District of Eastern Missouri March 22, 1883 (Greenwalt v. Duncan)

Also known as

United States · · · 22-03-1883

Treat, J.

The unquestioned rule obtains in all cases in equity to remove a cloud upon a title that it must be clear that plaintiff has not a full, complete, and adequate remedy at law; otherwise he will be remitted to his common-law remedy. This, under the constitution of the United States, the acts of congress, and repeated decisions of the United States supreme court, is an inflexible rtíle. Mere questions as to conflicts of supposeddegal titles can ordinarily be decided in actions of ejectment.

Plaintiff’s right in this case to sue in equity rests solely on the fact that, being in possession, they cannot sue the adverse parties at law. They set out in their bill with great fullness the pretended title of the defendants, as well as their own derivative title. The defendants file a cross-bill designed to be defensive in part, but to a large extent affirmative. The purpose of the pleader is to urge the superiority of defendants’ title and to have a decree settling the whole controversy. To the cross-bill two pleas have been interposed and argued.

The first is that, inasmuch as the cross-bill does not aver possession in th"e defendants, their remedy as for affirmative relief is at law; that is, if persons are not in possession of real estate to which they have paramount title, they should be driven to their action of ejectment. That plea rests upon a misapplication of the general rule stated. The plaintiffs are in court for the sole reason that they are in possession, and therefore have brought in the defendants, who are out of possession, to answer to the demand made. The defendants, *37being thus in court at plaintiffs’ instance, have a right, by answer or cross-bill, to be fully heard, and not to be denied a full hearing because the sole basis, jurisdictionally, of plaintiffs’ bill is true.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.