Texas Supreme Court June 15, 1884 (Herschell v. L. & H. Blum)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-06-1884

OPINIOIV.

The first assignment of error relates to the following state of facts: The plaintiff introduced the witness House to prove that in 1876, L. Herschell and wife bought a lot in Cleburne; they then proved by House certain declarations by L- Herschell about the manner in which the lot was paid for and what was done with it. To this the claimant objected, chiefly on the ground that statements made by the husband could not be received to the detriment of the wife’s separate rights of property. But it does not clearly appear from the bill of exceptions that the lot in question was bought and'treated by the parties as the separate property of the wife. In the absence, therefore, of something more definite, we must conclude that the ruling of the court was correct.

The second assignment complains of the ninth paragraph of the *179charge of the court, that to entitle Mrs. Herschell to recover, she must trace, by clear and satisfactory evidence, her separate funds through all the changes and mitigations through which the same may have passed, down to the property in question.

Counsel objects to this charge: 1st, because the jury are told that the evidence must be “clear and satisfactory.” We see no objection to this lauguage. Presumptively the property would be community. To repel this presumption, the evidence ought to be clear and satisfactory to the jury. The other objection is wholly without “merit, because the judge, in speaking of Mrs. Herschell, says that “She must trace by clear and satisfactory proof,” counsel infer that the impression was thus made upon the jury that the facts must be established by the testimony of Mrs. Herschell herself, and that they could not deduce them from the other evidence in the case.

In our opinion, the whole paragraph taken together would not be likely to mislead the jury. This disposes of the third assignment as well as the second.

We do not think it necessary to follow the assignments of error in their order any further.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.