Supreme Court of Alabama December 15, 1884 (Lee v. Lee)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-12-1884
STONE, O. J.
The bill in this case was filed by Mrs. Lee, and its purpose is to have dower allotted to her in two tracts of land, described in the pleadings. The bill avers that, during the coverture, her husband, Richard IT. Lee, was seized in fee of the entire interest in six hundred and forty acres of land, known as the “Prairie place,” and of an undivided half in*417terest in another tract, containing about eighteen hundred acres, known as the “ Muckle place.” Each of the tracts of land is described by Government-survey numbers. It is not controverted that complainant has fully established her claim to dower in each of the tracts, looking alone to her side of the case. All the affirmative conditions — marriage, seizin of the husband during the coverture, and his death — are fully proved. The lands were aliened during the life of the husband, and the wife did not join therein.
Much parol testimony was taken in the court below, and many exceptions were filed to parts of it. Large part of the testimony of complainant herself was objected to, and to some extent these objections are well founded. — Gordon v. Tweedy, 71 Ala. 202. There is other testimony to which exceptions were well taken, but it is not our intention to pass on the many exceptions. Enough legal testimony remains to establish the facts hereinafter stated.
The defense relied on in bar of complainant’s right of dower is two-fold : First, that the lands were partnership property, owned by Richard Ií. Lee and James Lee as partners, and that they were sold in payment of partnership liabilities. This defense is properly abandoned by defendants, for the proof is insufficient to make it good.
The second defense pleaded and relied on in bar of complainant’s claim of dower is, that at the time of the husband’s death, and at the time complainant filed her bill in this cause, she had and owned a separate estate of equal or greater value than her dower interest in her husband’s, estate.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit