Supreme Court of Alabama December 15, 1884 (Berry v. Webb)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-12-1884

SOMERVILLE, J.

The present bill is filed for the purpose of correcting an alleged misdescription of certain lands conveyed by one John Berry, in the year 1872, to the appellant, William Berry, and Elizabeth Webb, then Elizabeth ITeatherington ; and for the further purpose of having a partition of these lands decreed as between appellant, who -was complainant in the lower court, and said Elizabeth Webb — the two grantees in the conveyance thus being averred to be tenants in common.

We entertain no doubt of the jurisdiction of the court to grant the relief prayed, notwithstanding the fact that the complainant is shown to have been out of possession for many years prior to the filing of the bill, and the defendant, Mrs. Webb, in possession holding adversely for a period of timeless than ten years, so that her title had not become perfect under the influence of the statute of limitations. The correction of mistakes of description in written instruments, established by clear and satisfactory proof, so as to make them conform to the true intention of the contracting parties, is a common ground of equity jurisdiction. — Berry v. Sowell, 72 Ala. 14; Alexander v. Caldwell, 55 Ala. 517; 1 Story’s Eq. Jur. §§ 165-166. So, likewise, is the partition of property owned by joint tenants, or tenants in common. — Deloney v. Walker, 9 Port. 497. This jurisdiction to decree partition exists, whether the title is legal or equitable. When purely legal, the practice is, often, to refer the determination of disputed titles to a jury, to be tried as an issue of fact. — Code, 1876, § 3893 ; McMath v. DeBardelaben, 75 Ala. 68. But, where the title is equitable, the whole question is for the decision of the chancellor, without the intervention of a court of law; equitable titles being peculiarly within the cognizance of courts of equity, and receiving no recognition in courts of law. — Willard’s Eq. Jur. 704. It is observed in Adams’ Equity (7th Amer. Ed.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.