Oregon Supreme Court March 15, 1884 (Sheppard v. Yocum)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-03-1884

By the Court,

Lord, J.:

This is an appeal from an order refusing to dissolve an attachment, and from the judgment entered in the cause after a trial and verdict upon the merits. Of the several errors assigned as affecting the judgment, after careful consideration we have reached the conclusion that none of them are sustained, and that the judgment must be affirmed.

The only other error relied on is the refusal of the court to dissolve the attachment. It is insisted by respondent that no appeal lies from this order, for the reason that such *235order is not within the meaning or the purview of section 525 of the code, which prescribes that “an appeal only lies from an order affecting a substantial right, which, in effect, determines the action or suit so as to prevent a judgment or decree therein, or a final order affecting a substantial right, and made in a proceeding after judgment or decree,” and that such order cannot be reviewed on an appeal from the judgment, for the further reason that the court, on an appeal from a judgment, under section 535 of the code, can only “review an intermediate order involving the merits, and necessarily affecting the j udgment.” This question has been answered both in the affirmative and negative by the supreme court of California, under provisions of their statute substantially like our own at the time such decisions were rendered.

In Taaffe v. Rosenthal, 7 Cal., 518, it was held an appeal will lie, after final judgment, from an order refusing to discharge an attachment; Baldwin, J., saying: “This objection would not seem to be well founded. It would practically destroy the appellate power of this court conferred by the constitution. If true, the defendant, however great may have been the injury sustained by him in consequence of the wrongful issuing of the attachment, could have no remedy when the order of the court below should be against him.”

But in Allender v. Fritz, 24 Cal.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.