Supreme Court of Colorado February 29, 1884 (Kiskadden v. Allen)

Also known as

United States · · · 29-02-1884

Stone, J.

The action in the Court below was by appellee against appellant upon the following instrument, to wit:

“ $284.00. Denver, Colorado, Jan. 12, 1882.

“ On or before March 12,1882, after date, I promise to pay to the order of J. 0. Allen two hundred and eighty-four dollars, at the City National Bank, with interest ten per cent, per annum. Value received. This note becomes due and payable when (if before March 12, 1882,) Allen, Burke & Co. shall dispose of a part or all their interest in the New York Hotel, or when the interest of M. C. Burke may be sold or disposed of.

“(Signed) M, C. Burke.”

And endorsed, “William Kisk'adden,”

*494Appellee got judgment for $298.75, which judgment the appellant, Kiskadden, asks to have reversed, on the grounds that:

First—The instrument sued on is not a promissory note.

Second—That there was no consideration for the signing by appellant.

Third—That appellant was discharged by merger of the contract in a prior judgment in favor of appellee against Burke.

Fourth—That appellant was merely a surety, and was discharged by the conduct of appellee.

Upon the first ground it is argued that the instrument is not payable at a time certain, and that it is not payable at all events.

We think these objections are opposed to a fair construction of the instrument. The body of the obligation is a definite promise to pay at a time certain; it is in the usual form of an ordinary promissory note. The words appended to the body of the note provide, that if the interest of Allen, Burke & Co., or that of Burke alone, in a certain hotel, shall be sold before the date of maturity of the note, then the note shall become due and payable upon the happening of the event of such sale. This was a contingency which might or might not happen; but whether it happened or not, the note, by express terms, became payable upon a certain day mentioned.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.