U.S. Circuit Court for the District of Massachusetts March 12, 1884 (Shaw Relief Valve Co. v. City of New Bedford)

Also known as

United States · · · 12-03-1884

Lowell, J.

This bill is brought upon two patents, and the demurrer of the city of New Bedford raises several objections, all but-*754one of which, it is agreed, can be, and may be, removed by amendment. A question which cannot be thus disposed of, and which has been argued with earnestness, and is pending in at least one other circuit, is whether the complainant’s title to an undivided part of one of the patents is sufficient. It seems that this title comes through an administrator of the patentee; and the defendant contends that the grant of a patent, by Rev. St. § 4884, is to the patentee, “his heirs and assigns,” and that by force of these words a patent descends directly to the heirs, without the intervention of the administrator. This is a new and somewhat surprising proposition. It has never been doubted beforeihat a patent is personal property, which follows the ordinary course, and goes to the executor or administrator in trust for the next of kin. The cases take this for granted, and when any question has been mooted, it has had reference to the due qualification of the executor or administrator, or something of that sort, as in Rubber Co. v. Goodyear, 9 Wall. 788. The text-writers treat of patent-rights as personal property which goes to the executor. Norman, Pat. 145; Schouler, Ex’rs, § 200. The defendant argues that the statute of 1870 changed the rule, by omitting the words “executors and administrators” from what is now section 4884, intending to make a sort of real estate of this incorporeal right. He has not argued that the widow can be endowed of it, but I suppose that will follow. A grant of personal property to a man and his heirs, without further qualification, means to him and his next of kin, according to the statute of distributions. 4 Kent, Comm. (5th Ed.) 537, note d, and cases; Vaux v. Henderson, 1 Jacob & W. 388n; Gittings v. McDermott, 2 Mylne & K. 69; Re Newton’s Trusts, L. R. 4 Eq. 171; Re Gryll’s Trusts, L. R. 6 Eq.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.