Supreme Court of the United States March 3, 1884, 163 (Swann v. Clark)

Also known as

United States · · · 03-03-1884

Me. Justice HaelaN

delivered the opinion of the court.

¿This case is an outgrowth of a foreclosure suit brought by the trustees in a first mortgage executed by the Alabama

&

Chattanooga Railroad Company upon its road, property, rights, and franchises, to secure the payment of bonds by it- issued. The history of that suit is given in the opinion just rendered in

Swann

v.

Wright's Ex'or.

The terms of the several orders and decrees in the foreclosure suit, so fay as they affect the rights of parties now before us, are set forth in that opinion, and need not be here repeated.

Among the claims presented against the trust fund in the foreclosure suit was one by appellee. Clark'for alleged loans made to the receivers, for which the latter hypothecated to him forty-five receivers’ certificates. Commissioner Phillips found that such hypothecation was unauthorized by the orders of the court under and in virtue of which the certificates were issued. But he reported that upon principles of equity those claims, to the extent of moneys actually advanced to the receivers and applied to the benefit of the trust estate, should be allowed and paid in certificates, at ninety cents on the dollar. The amount advanced by Clark was ascertained to be $16,760.89 ; and for that sum, with interest to September 1st, 1875, amounting in all to $19,658.01, the commissioner reported that he. should be allowed, in certificates, the sum of $21,842.23. These conclusions were sustained by, the court; but, as it appeared .that the Clark certificates were, or were supposed to be, in the hands o¡f different parties, and inasmuch as the rights of those parties could not be determined from the reports of the commissioner, those certificates were not allowed, and the parties were required to litigate their respective rights with each other, by bills filed in the same court, thereby “ to ascertain and settle the amount that the said trust fund is.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.