Supreme Court of the United States November 10, 1884 (Scotland County v. Hill)
Also known as
United States · · · 10-11-1884
Mr. Chief Justice Waite
delivered the opinion of the court. He stated the facts in the foregoing language, and continued:
All the rejected evidence was, in our' opinion, improperly excluded. The decree in the Wagner suit was set up as a bar to the action, on the ground that the liability of the county for the coupons was
res judicata
between the parties. The suit, although brought by citizens and tax-payers of the county, ivas, in effect, the same as though brought by the county itself to test the validity of the subscription which had been, made to the stock of the company and the power of the County Court to bind the county to pay the bonds which it was proposed to issue for the subscription. The county ivas itself a party through the justices of the County Court, which, in Missouri, is the governing board and represents the county in all such matters. The whole purpose of the suit was to keep the bonds from the market as commercial paper, and to have them cancelled. The suit was about the bonds and the liability of the county thereon. The decree was in accordance with the prayer of the bill, and certainly concluded both Metz and the railroad company. After the rendition of this decree the company could not sue and recover on the bonds, because, as between the company and the county, it had been directly adjudicated that the bonds were void and of no binding effect on the county. But it is equally well settled that the decree binds not only Metz and the company, but all who bought the bonds after the suit was begun, and who were chargeable with notice of its pendency or of the decree which was rendered. The case of
County of Warren
v. Marcy, 97 U. S. 96, decides that purchasers of negotiable securities are not chargeable with
constructive
notice of1 the .
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit