Supreme Court of North Carolina February 5, 1885 (State v. . Butts)

Also known as

United States · · · 05-02-1885

Akiie, J.

(after stating the facts). The section of

The Code

under which the indictment was drawn is as follows:

“If any person shall wilfully overdrive, overload, wound, injure, torture, torment, deprive of necessary sustenance, or cruelly beat, or needlessly mutilate, or kill, or cause or procure to be overridden, overloaded, wounded, injured, tortured; tormented, or deprived of necessary sustenance, or to be cruelly beaten, needlessly mutilated, or killed, as aforesaid, any useful beast, fowl or animal, every such offender shall, for every such offence, be guilty of a misdemeanor.”

The Code,

§2482.

At the first blush we Avere doubtful AA'hether the indictment in this case could be sustained, because it does not folhrw the words of the statute; — but, upon consideration, we are of the opinion it is sufficient. The indictment charges the defendant with

shooting

the cow. Shooting is not mentioned in the statute, but the’ wounding of animals is forbidden, and 'the shooting necessarily includes wounding. In the

State

v.

Lonon,

22 Miss., 449, it is said: “In criminal cases’the definition of

wound

is an injury tó the person by which the skin is broken.”

*787

We cannot well imagine a case of injury by shooting where the

skin

is not broken, and Archbold, in his work on Criminal Pleadings, lays down the doctrine to be: “ When a word not in the statute is substituted in the indictment for one that is, and the word thus substituted is equivalent ‘to the word used in the statute, or is of more extensive signification than it, the indictment will be sufficient.” See also

State

v. Stanton, 1 Ired., 424.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.