Supreme Court of North Carolina October 5, 1885 (Dawkins v. . Dawkins)

Also known as

United States · · · 05-10-1885

Ashe, J.,

(after stating the facts). This case is so incomplete in the statement of the facts, that we feel sensible of our inability to reach the justice of the case, trammeled as we are by the findings of facts and exceptions thereto. All we can do is to give a partial adjudication upon the case.

*289

The first exeeption by defendants, that the Court found as a fact that the deed of John A. McDonald and W. K. Dawkins to A. C. and D. C. Patterson, conveyed only the interest of W. K. Dawkins in the land, is well taken, for the deed which accompanies the record as an exhibit, shows that the entire tract of land was conveyed. But that, in the view we take of the case, is immaterial.

The second exception to the finding, “ that Randolph McDonald sold and conveyed his interest in the land to W. K. Dawkins, because it is not supported by the testimony” — cannot be sustained. It is supported by the testimony of A. C. Patterson, who swore that the clerk made a deed to McDonald and McDonald conveyed to Dawkins.

The third

exception-

— ■“ Because the Court failed to find that the infant heirs of Randolph McDonald have not been served with notice of this motion.” This exception is without merit, because it was shown by the testimony of A. C. Patterson, that McDonald had disposed of his interest, and his heirs having no interest were not necessary parties.

The fourth exception to the finding, “ that McDonald as surety was forced to pay the purchase money.” We cannot see what difference it could make whether the payment was voluntary or involuntary.

The fifth exception:

“

Because his Honor failed to find that the Pattersons have been in the adverse possession of the lands for more than seven years prior to the commencement of this proceeding.” This exception is without foundation, for the Court did find that A. C. and D. C. Patterson took actual possession of said land on the 5th day of February, A. D., 1877, and have had possession since that time.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.