Court of Appeals of Texas May 6, 1885, No. 3437 (Cannon v. State)
Also known as
United States · · · 06-05-1885
Hurt, Judge.
This is a conviction for theft of hogs, the punishment being two years’ confinement in the penitentiary.
Hpon the trial defendant offered to prove the market value of hogs of like size of the hogs charged to have been stolen. To this evidence the State objected, and the court sustained the objection, and defendant reserved his bill of exceptions. The proof of the State in regard to the value of the hogs was, in effect, that they were worth, the sow $12, and the barrow $10; that the sow would have weighed about one hundred and seventy-five or one hundred and eighty pounds, and the barrow about one hundred and thirty-five or one hundred and forty pounds. “That the sow was worth $12 because she was of good stock and a good breeder. The barrow was intended for pork.” “ The sow had been spayed, but not clean, *173and still had hogs.” “ She would not have so many pigs, but they would be better ones, and she could raise them better.” The above is in substance the testimony of Mr. Spence, the owner of the hogs.
Jones, a witness for defendant, “ Knew the hogs well; did not know what stock they were. They were just common range hogs.” At this point defendant proposed to prove by Jones the market value of such hogs as the Spence hogs, but was not permitted to do so by the court below. Upon what ground the objection to the proposed evidence was sustained we cannot perceive. It certainly was not because of the peculiar good stock and breeding qualities of the sow, for the barrow, though he may have been of good stock, was certainly valuable alone for pork.
But suppose that the State’s witness had sworn that these hogs were valuable because of certain qualities, is the defendant precluded from introducing evidence in contradiction of this fact? Can, in any case, the State’s theory be assumed to be true by the trial court, and, thus assuming, deny the defendant the right to adduce evidence which bears directly upon a material matter in the case? Most evidently not.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit