New York Supreme Court January 15, 1885 (Leonard v. American Baptist Home Mission Society)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-01-1885
Haight, J.:
This action was brought for the purpose of obtaining a judicial construction of the will of Cornelius Ten Broeck, deceased, and for a determination whether or not the contingency contemplated by the will on which a sale of real estate was authorized to be made, had not happened. The court at Special Term held and decided that the plaintiff was not entitled to maintain the action for the construction of the will alone, but that she was entitled to maintain the action for the purpose of determining whether or not the contingency upon which a sale of the land was authorized has not happened in accordance with the true intent and meaning thereof. *292An interlocutory judgment was ordered and entered referring it to a referee to take the proofs that may be offered before him for the purpose of showing the amount which it may be necessary to raise to supply the plaintiff’s wants during her natural life, and the portion of the testator’s real estate which should be sold for that purpose, and to report the same to the court. The defendants appeal from this judgment.
It is contended in the first place that the complaint in the action does not authorize the judgment entered. The complaint sets out the will and all of the facts, it then asks for a judicial construction of the will upon various subjects, and in addition thereto it asks for a determination as to whether or not the contingency has not happened upon which a sale of the real estate was authorized according to the true intent, meaning and design of the will. It appears to us that this is broad enough to authorize the court to ascertain and determine whether or not the contingency has happened, and this question will be determined on the execution of the reference provided by the interlocutory judgment.
It remains to bé determined whether or not the duty devolves upon the court to determine the contingency and the amount of real estate it is necessary to sell, if any.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit