New York Supreme Court November 15, 1885 (Vanderwerken v. Brown)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-11-1885
Learned, P. J.:
The plaintiff sued in Justices’ Court for killing his dog and was beaten. He appealed to the County Court demanding a new trial and recovered three dollars. The clerk taxed costs in plaintiff’s favor. The County Court refused to set aside the taxation, and the defendant appeals. The question is upon the part of section 3070 of the Code in these words: “ If an offer is not made and the verdict, report or decision upon the appeal is more favorable to the appellant by the sum of ten dollars than the verdict or decision of the court below” * * * “the appellant is entitled to recover costs upon the appeal, otherwise the respondent is entitled to recover costs.” Does the clause fairly apply to a case where in the County Court there is not simply a reduction, or an increase, of the recovery below, but where the recovery is for the party who was defeated below ?
In Quirk v. Wixon (27 Hun, 592) the plaintiff recovered eight dollars in Justices’ Court. The defendant appealed, and on a new trial in County Court the plaintiff was beaten. It was held that defendant was entitled to costs. The same was decided in Snyder v. Hughes (27 Hun, 374), in a similar case.
We are referred to no other cases on this point. These should control us. They are like the present case, except that in the cases cited there was a recovery for the plaintiff below and a failure to recover above. Here it is the reverse. But the principle is the same. And we think the decisions are sound. A party who recovers one sum in the court below and a somewhat larger sum above has only increased his damages. And if he has not increased them by ten dollars, he may properly be required to pay costs.
But one who was beaten in the court below, and then recovers in the court above has established that lie was right in bringing the action, and that tbe defendant was in the wrong.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit