Wisconsin Supreme Court September 22, 1885 (Bunn v. Valley Lumber Co.)
Also known as
United States · · · 22-09-1885
Cole, 0. <J.
At the outset it must be borne in mind that the circuit court had the power to vacate its order submitting to a jury the question whether the - defendant, when it purchased the logs, had actual notice of the hen which the. action was brought to enforce. The action was one in equity, consequently it was entirely competent for the circuit court to try ah the issues and determine ah the questions of law and fact without the intervention of a jury. If the court saw fit in its discretion to submit any question of fact to a jury, the verdict, when rendered, would be merely advisory, and not binding upon the judgment of the court. The case was not one within sec. 2814, E. S., involving issues which the defendant had the right to have tried by a jury and other issues triable by the court. But all the issues in the case were triable by the court, which might submit any question of fact to the jury, and might disregard the verdict and make its own finding thereon.. There can be no doubt as to the correctness of this view, and it is not necessary to cite authorities in support of it. It was not error for the court to vacate its order submitting the question of notice to the jury, and to try that, with all other questions of fact arising in the case, giving the' parties an opportunity to be heard upon all the issues in the case. We have said that it was within the power and discretion of the court to do this, if that course seemed advisable and would promote the ends of justice.
The main inquiry on this appeal is, Did the circuit court consider and decide all the issues in the cause as if no jury *632Rad been called to its aid? This is an appeal from the order refusing to set aside the judgment. There is no bill of exceptions containing “ the minutes of the court and the testimony in the case ” which were before the court when it decided the motion.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit