Indiana Supreme Court January 30, 1885, No. 10,998 (Adams v. Sullivan)
Also known as
United States · · · 30-01-1885
Niblack, J.
The appellants, David M. Adams and James C. Adams, doing business in the firm name of the Adams Packing Company, were, during the summer and fall of the year 1881, the proprietors of a warehouse in the city of Indianapolis, containing what was known as 'a “ cold storage' room,” claimed to be, amongst other things, specially adapted to the storage of eggs and butter. The appellee, John E. Sullivan, was, during the same period of time, in the general produce business in the same city, which included the purchase, handling and sale of eggs and butter. Commencing on the 8th day of June and ending on the 5th day of September in said year 1881, Sullivan deposited'in the cold storage room in question the aggregate amount of two hundred and twenty-nine barrels of eggs and fifty or more tubs of butter for safe-keeping. When Sullivan withdrew these barrels of eggs and tubs of butter for sale and consumption late in the fall, he claimed to have found them 'all in a more or less damaged condition, and this action was instituted for the alleged failure of the appellants to take proper care of the eggs and butter while stored in their warehouse. Verdict for the plaintiff at special term, assessing his damages at the sum of $897.50. New trial denied, and judgment on the verdict. Judgment affirmed at general term.
As regards the eggs, the manner in which they were handled, .stored and prepared for market, was first shown by the evidence. It was in this way made to appear that when eggs were gathered in either by wagons or from shipments by railroad, they were put into a dark room, where they were examined and tested by an employee of - the plaintiff known to-*10those engaged in buying and selling eggs as a “candler.” This examination was made by the candler placing each egg between his eyes and a light, by means of which he was enabled to test the quality of each egg, and to classify it accordingly.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit