Supreme Court of Iowa April 8, 1885 (Raridon v. Central Iowa Railway Co.)
Also known as
United States · · · 08-04-1885
Rothrock, J.
The petition and the amendment thereto set forth, in substance, that the defendant’s railroad was lawfully constructed over and across plaintiff’s farm, and that by the construction of the road the plaintiff’s inclosed and fenced fields were thrown open, and that defendant neglected and refused for the period of about one year to place cattle-guards at the proper places, and that by reason of said failure and neglect the plaintiff’s fields were thrown open to the public; that plaintiff had on his farm 103 acres of heavy grass, of the value of $2.50 per acre, and 30 acres of corn-stalks, of the value of $1 per acre, for the winter of 1882-83, and the value of the same was destroyed; that he owned 100 cattle, *641for which he had saved said grass and stalks, and that he could not turn his herd into said pasture because of said openings in the fences, and that he could not protect himself from the loss of the pasture by any reasonable means. lie claimed damages in the sum of $300.
The demurrer was to the effect that the petition failed to show that the neglect to put in cattle-guards resulted in depriving the plaintiff of the use of his winter pasture, and failed to state any fact showing how such failure to put in cattle-guards resulted in any legal damage to the plaintiff; and that the facts pleaded show that the plaintiff’s loss of his pasture resulted from his groundless fears and voluntary-omission to feed and use the same; and that the damages, sought to be recovered are remote, speculative and consequential.
The statute requires that every railroad company shall make proper cattle-guards where its railway enters or leaves any improved or fenced land, and shall be liable for all damages sustained by reason of such neglect and refusal. Code, § 1288. And the owner of the land has no legal right to construct cattle-guards across the track, and is not bound to do so to protect himself from damages by reason of the want thereof. Downing v. Chicago, R. I.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit