Supreme Court of Iowa December 16, 1885 (Goodnow v. Oakley)

Also known as

United States · · · 16-12-1885

Adams, J.

1. pleading: plaintiff: more specific statement. I. The defendant filed a motion for an order that the plaintiff be required to make his petition more specific by stating whether he sued in his own right or as trustee. The court overruled the ° , „ . . . , . motion, and the defendant complains that the court erred in so doing. The petition avers, in substance, that the taxes were paid by the Iowa Homestead Company, and that the claim arising in its favor by reason of such payment was duly assigned by such company to the plaintiff. A copy of the assignment is set out, which, to.our mind, shows the right on the part of the plaintiff to prosecute the action in his own name, and we cannot think it material whether he does so nominally in his own right or as trustee

2. removal fedear8ueeourt: iffainUitf citizenship of cestui que trust not considered. II. The defendant filed a petition for a removal of the cause to the circuit court of the United States. The court refused to grant the petition, and the defendant contends that the court erred in such refusal. The claimed right of removal was based upon ..... , . -r . the ground ot citizenship. It is not denied that 2=1 ^ ‡ tlie plaintiff and defendant are citizens of the same state, to-wit, the state of New York; but the defendant avers in her petition that the plaintiff is- not the real party in interest, and has no interest, but is prosecuting the action for the benefit of the Iowa Homestead Company and the Dubuque & Sioux City Railroad Company, both of which corporations are organized under the laws of Iowa. A question as to a right of removal arose upon a similar state of facts in Goodnow v. Litchfield, 67 Iowa, 691, decided at the present term, and it was held in that case that the right of removal did not exist.

*273. notary of foreign'11 cienoy of!' 1 *26III. The plaintiff applied for a change of venue from the circuit court to the district court of Webster county.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.