New York Court of Appeals October 5, 1886 (Conselyea v. . Blanchard)

Also known as

United States · · · 05-10-1886

Earl, J.

The only claim the plaintiffs have to share in the fund in controversy and to have priority therein is based upon the two orders taken by their testator, for the first of which he paid $850, and for the second of which he paid $595. There was no evidence that the money thus advanced bore any rela

*227

tian to, or had any connection with, the bridge or its erection, and the plaintiffs claim priority of payment solely on the ground that these orders are prior in date to the other orders.

Blanchard

&

O’Rourke base their claim to priority of payment upon facts found by the judge at Special Term as follows: They were the owners of a certain patent for the construction of bridge turn-tables, which were known and designated as “ Blanchard & O’Rourke patent turn-tables,” and as such patentees they had the exclusive right to construct and use such turn-tables; and Swift & Van Aken by their contract with the two counties were bound to furnish such a turn-table. For the purpose of performing their contract with the counties, Swift & Van Aken entered into contract with Blanchard

&

O’Rourke to furnish, supply and erect one of these turn-tables for the price of $2,500, $2,000 of which was to be paid when the turn-table should be complete, in running order and accepted as such, and the balance of $500, when the bridge should be accepted by the counties. By the contract of Swift & Van Aken with the counties it was provided that the work on the bridge should be commenced within ten days and finished within sixty days after the completion and delivery of the central pier, and if there was delay beyond that time, they agreed to pay as liquidated damages to the counties, the sum of $50 per day for every day of such delay, the amount to be retained from the contract-price stipulated to be paid by the counties.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.