Supreme Court of North Carolina February 5, 1886 (Hedrick v. . Pratt)
Also known as
United States · · · 05-02-1886
The plaintiff introduced a mortgage from John S. Hedrick to himself, to secure a note therein recited, payable to the plaintiff. He showed that the defendant had purchased the mare described in the deed, and was still in possession. It was admitted that the mortgagor, J. S. Hedrick, had died before the commencement of this action. Plaintiff was offered as a witness in his own behalf, and was asked "if the debt secured in the mortgage had been paid?" To this question the defendant objected as incompetent. The Court reserving the question of law, admitted the question, and the witness answered, "It has not been paid in full." The plaintiff then proposed to prove by himself as a witness, that the note described in the mortgage was in his possession, and had been since the execution of the mortgage to him. To this the defendant objected — the Court, reserving the question of law, permitted the plaintiff to answer as above set forth. Plaintiff then proposed to read the note to the jury, and the defendant objected, and upon its appearing to the Court that there was a subscribing witness to the note, who resided in the State, and was not present, the Court declined to permit it to be read. No other evidence was offered. *Page 111 Upon the facts and proofs submitted, his Honor directed a verdict to be entered finding all issues in favor of the plaintiff, subject to the opinion of the Court on questions of law reserved. The Court, upon consideration of all the law bearing upon the case, being of opinion with the defendant, directed the verdict to be stricken out. Whereupon the plaintiff took a non-suit and appealed. It is a well settled rule of practice in this State, that when on the trial, the Court intimates an opinion that the plaintiff cannot maintain the action, he may, in deference to the opinion of the Court, submit to a judgment of non-suit, assign ground of error, and appeal to this Court.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit