Supreme Court of North Carolina October 5, 1886 (Benton v. . Benton)

Also known as

United States · · · 05-10-1886

Smith, C. J.

The action is to recover possession of two tracts of land, described separately in the complaint, upon an averment of title in the plaintiffs, which is controverted in the answer. In support of the claim, the plaintiffs introduced in evidence a deed executed on June 29th, 1850, by W. B. McCorkle to Stephen W. Cole, Edmond J. Waddell and Hampton B. Harman, alleged to convey the larger of the disputed tracts, in trust to secure a large indebtedness and liability then resting on him.

II. A deed for the same, made December 18th, 1852, by the trustees, to William A. Benton and Archibald C. Benton.

III. A deed from Archibald C. Benton and James C. Car-raway, assuming to act as trustee, under a conveyance from the former, for the undivided moiety of the tract, to the other tenant in common, William A. Benton.

IV. The will of the last named, dated May 1st, 1862, and proved in April, 1864, devising all the testator’s lands to his brother, Archibald 0., and sister Elizabeth, constituting the former trustee, to secure the separate estate of the latter.

*561

The evidence to sustain the plaintiff’s claim to the second or smaller tract, consists in a deed from William Hasker and others, to said Archibald 0., and from the latter to the testator, William A. Benton. The Court ruled that these were insufficient to divert title out of the State and put it in the plaintiffs, and the issue was thus made to depend on an estoppel, arising out of a contract of renting. It was shown that W. Henry Benton, husband of the defendant Sarah, was employed to oversee on the plantation when carried on by vV. B. McCorkle, and moved upon it with his family about the year 1847 or 1848, and died in 1858. Since this, she has continued to occupy the premises.

In March, 1865, she executed a note, payable to the heirs of W. A.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.