Supreme Court of North Carolina February 5, 1886 (Sellars v. Richmond & Danville Railroad)
Also known as
United States · · · 05-02-1886
Smith, C. J.
(after stating the facts). If the action had been brought against the organization to the mismanagement and inexcusable negligence of whose servants the intestate’s injuries, and consequent loss of life, are directly attributable, there would be no legal defence against its successful prosecution, and the recovery of damages. But it is a different question, when the claim is asserted against the defendant. Its servants had no control over the cars, which had been delivered to the servants of the Columbia company, nearly an hour previous, nor could they exercise any authority over the action of the latter. The inquiry now is, wherein is found the acts or omissions of the defendant, or its employés, out of which springs its responsibility to the plaintiff’s intestate, or to the plaintiff, and how the negligence of the servants of the other company can be legally imputed to the defendant, so as to subject it to the claim for compensatory damages.
The first issue submitted to the jury was in this form : Was the death of the plaintiff’s intestate caused by the negligence of the defendant ? The response rendered being in the affirmative.
The series of instructions asked for by the defendant, present the case in its different aspects upon the evidence, underlying all of which, is the comprehensive proposition, that no negligence on the part of the defendant’s servants is shown, entitling the plaintiff to the recovery of damages from it. This requires of Uus to examine the directions of the Court, and the grounds upon which the jurors were authorized to act, in imputing negligence to the defendant’s servants, for which their principal is liable.
*658
The Court instructed the jury, that there was no negligence in the defendant, in allowing the other Company to use their switch in making connection between the roads, to facilitate the interchange of freight between them.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit