New York Supreme Court February 15, 1886 (People ex rel. Butler v. Hunting)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-02-1886

Dykman, J.:

The law has invested the commissioners of highways of the towns of this'State with power to command the removal of obstructions and encroachments from the highways whenever, in their opinion, it shall be necessary.

The mode of procedure prescribed is to make a written order on the subject, and also to give notice in writing to the occupant and owner of the land, to remove such obstructions or encroachments within sixty days. If the occupant to whom such notice is given shall within five days deny such encroachment the commissioners shall apply to a justice of the peace of the county for a precept, directed to a constable of the town, to summon twelve freeholders thereof to meet and inquire into the prexnises. On the assembling of the jux-y they must be swonx by the justice to inquii’e whether any such encroachment has been made and by whom. This is the scheme of the statutes, as they are now in force, without reference to particular sections or amendments.

One of the defendants in this proceeding is the sole commissioner of highways of the town of Sxnithtown, in Suffolk county, and he received a complaint that the relator had obstracted one of the highways of his town with gates. He examined the road and ascertained that the x’elator had ex-ected gates across the road in two places. Thereupon he made the order and served the notice required by the statute in such eases. Within the legal period the relator served a wi’itten denial of the obstruction in which he said, among other things, “ I beg to assui’e you that you are mistaken in supposing that the gates T have erected and am maintaining obstruct any highway.” Thereupon the commissioner made application to the other defendant in this proceeding for the precept for the jury to make the inquiry prescribed by the statute.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.