Wisconsin Supreme Court February 2, 1886 (Kelly v. Wright)

Also known as

United States · · · 02-02-1886

Lyoh, J.

The testimony is in conflict on the question whether the defendant employed the plaintiff to work for him on his farm. The jury found that he did so employ the plaintiff, and there is sufficient testimony to support the verdict in that behalf. The defendant was therefore primarily liable for the wages of the plaintiff earned in such service. The amount of damages recovered is also within the testimony, and does not exceed the sum for which judgment is demanded in the complaint.

The only other questions which require consideration arise upon tfte testimony concerning a settlement of the cause of action, and the rulings of the circuit judge thereon. It appears that before This action was brought the plaintiff sued both of the Wrights for the same wages. TIis attorney in that suit negotiated a settlement thereof with Edward M. Wright, and took his note for $80, payable in eight monthly instalments, in satisfaction of the plaintiff’s claim, and then discontinued the suit.

Such attorney was called as a witness by the defendant, and testified to the above facts, subject to an objection to his competency. He was examined fully in the case, and further testified, under like objection, that four or five days after he took the note he met plaintiff at the train to give it to him; that plaintiff said the note was of no use, that witness might keep it, and let Wright pay the money, and send it to him. Some months later, perhaps a year, witness mailed the note to plaintiff, who within three days thereafter returned it to the witness and repudiated the settlement. The witness further testified as follows: “ I think he knew of my taking the note-within a week after I did so. I am not positive. I either wrote him or saw him on the train at that time.” In his charge to the jury the judge ruled out the testimony of the attorney as incompetent.

Nothing was ever paid on the note, and the same attorney testified that he informed plaintiff that he could not collect it.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.