Supreme Court of Iowa June 15, 1886 (McMahill v. McMahill)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-06-1886

Rísed, J.

i estates of claim'ofheir oradvanfei6 denoV considered‘ Defendant’s father purchased the land in question in the year 1875, and took the title thereto in his own name- Soon after the purchase defendant went into possession of the land, and erected thereon a dwelling house and other buildings. He also enclosed it, but the fencing material, or the greater portion of it, was purchased and paid for by his father. He continued to occupy and cultivate the place until the death of his father, which occurred in 1881, and he did not account to his father for the rent of the place during any portion of that time. The annual taxes on the place during the time, however, were paid by the father. It is shown that the father, on frequent occasions after the purchase, spoke of the place as belonging to defendant, and stated that he had purchased it for him, and intended to give it to him. After his death a warranty deed conveying the premises to defendant was found among his papers. This deed was executed about two years before the death of the father, but it is not claimed that it had ever been delivered to defendant. The father died seized of a large amount of lands in the state of Illinois, where he had resided for many years before his death. In a proceeding had in one of the courts of that state after his death, partition of those lands was made among his heirs, one-ninth in value thereof being set off to defendant, and the lands so set off’ to him were subsequently sold by defendant for about the sum of $5,000.

The allegations in the cross-petition, that defendant purchased the land from his father by a parol contract, and that he had paid the purchase price thereof, are not directly supported by any competent evidence. Counsel for defendant *117contend, however, that the reasonable presumption or inference from the circumstances proven is that such contract had been entered into by the parties.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.